Evaluation

DHM280 · Project 2

The final verdict: how well the COVID-19 Twitter Pandemic Archive holds up against Digital Humanities best practices.

Screenshot of the Hydrator GitHub page saying it is no longer a useful application
Hydrator’s GitHub page: “no longer a useful application” after Twitter’s API changes. Screenshot, Documenting the Now

Scorecard

Documentation

Clear guides to the data, the files, the vaccine filter, and the dashboard. The missing piece is the collection script.

Strong

Openness

Free data with permanent DOIs, a free toolkit under an open license, and a public dashboard. Held back by Twitter’s paywall.

Strong, with limits

Transparency of method

The lab’s own choices are spelled out exactly, but the core collection rules belonged to Twitter and are now gone.

Mixed

Ethics and privacy

Sharing only IDs follows the platform’s rules and means deleted tweets stay deleted.

Strong

Sustainability

The project has ended. The IDs will survive on figshare, but Hydrator, the recommended rehydration tool, no longer works.

Weak

Biggest strength

It was built for other people. The lab didn’t just publish its own findings. It handed everyone the raw material and a tool to work with it, and then used that kind of data to publish real research (see Research Articles). That is exactly the shared infrastructure DH values.

Biggest weakness

Everything rests on a platform the lab doesn’t control. When Twitter changed its API rules in 2023, research using Twitter data dropped, and this archive became far harder to use. A stronger plan would have been to partner with an institution, such as a university library, that could legally hold the full tweets for researchers.

Overall

A strong archive on a fragile foundation

The COVID-19 Twitter Pandemic Archive gets most DH best practices right. It is open, well documented for users, careful about privacy, and it led to published research on how misinformation spreads. Its weaknesses are an unpublished collection script and its total dependence on Twitter.

It is a model for how Communication Studies and DH can work together, and a reminder that any archive of born-digital culture needs a plan for the day the platform changes.

Conclusion: grounds for collaboration

The bigger question for this project is whether Communication Studies and Digital Humanities have real grounds to work together. Based on this archive, my answer is yes.

Shared goals

Communication Studies wants to understand how misinformation spreads. DH wants to preserve and study public culture. One archive serves both.

Shared values

Both depend on transparency and openness. A claim about how false information spreads only convinces people if they can check the data behind it.

Shared tools

APIs, sampling large datasets, network analysis, and dashboards are everyday methods in both fields, and the Toolkit and Hydrator show the two communities already building on each other’s work.

Verdict: grounds established

Communication Studies brings the questions about how messages spread and why people believe them. DH brings the practices that keep the evidence open, documented, and preserved. The archive’s biggest weakness, its dependence on Twitter, is exactly the kind of preservation problem DH is good at solving, which makes the case for collaboration stronger, not weaker.

← ResultsWorks Cited →